| 2023 Leslie A. Dick |
| 2022 Leslie A. Dick |
| 2021 Stephen P. Warrington |
| 2020 Stephen P. Warrington |
| 2019 Robert W. Ricker |
| 2018 Robert W. Ricker |
| 2017 Christopher D. DeAngelo, Sr. |
| 2016 Walter F. Overington, Jr. |
| 2015 James M. Locklear, Sr., PSGS |
| 2014 James M. Locklear, Sr., PSGS |
| 2013 James M. Locklear, Sr., PSGS |
| 2012 Ezra Rickards |
| 2011 Douglas L. Boozer, Sr., PJGD |
| 2010 Linford P. Faucett, IV |
| 2009 Howard A. Kuhn, Jr. |
| 2008 Steven J. Whaley |
| 2007 William J. Esham, III |
| 2006 Alfred L. Collins, II |
| 2005 Barry W. Walls, Sr. |
| 2004 Howard A. Kuhn, Jr. |
| 2003 Haywood I. Buck, Jr. (*) |
| 2002 James E. Willey, Jr., PGM |
| 2001 James E. Willey, Jr., PGM |
| 2000 William J. Esham, III |
| 1999 William J. Esham, III |
| 1998 James E. Willey, Jr., PGM |
| 1997 James R. Schreppler |
| 1996 Brian W. Garner (**) |
| 1995 John N. Phillos |
| 1994 Steven J. Whaley |
| 1993 James R. Whaley (*) |
| 1992 James E. Willey, Jr., PGM |
| 1991 Dean A. Daisey |
| 1990 Haywood I. Buck, Jr. (*) |
| 1989 Louis J. Nobles, Jr. (*) |
| 1988 Alexander W. Nauss |
| 1987 Donald L. Murray (*) |
| 1986 James S. Barlow, Sr. (*) |
| 1985 Edward G. Sipple (*) |
| 1984 John A. Hoefer (*) |
| 1983 Dean A. Daisey |
| 1982 Warren O. Pettyjohn (*) |
| 1981 Richard M. Webb (*) |
| 1980 Robert D. Young |
| 1979 Richard M. Webb (*) |
| 1978 William I. Taylor, Sr. |
| 1977 Warren W. Edinger, Jr. (*) |
| 1976 J. Maurice Miller (*) |
| 1975 Richard M. Webb (*) |
| 1974 Lawrence D. Williams (*) |
| 1973 Ralph R. Elliott (*) |
| 1972 Warren W. Edinger, Jr. (*) |
| 1971 William Quesada (*) |
| 1970 Russel A. Lewis (*) |
| 1969 Ray W. Pettyjohn (*) |
| 1968 J. Maurice Miller (*) |
| 1967 Samuel W. Warrington |
| 1966 Lee R. Hill (*) |
| 1965 Benjamin T. Parker (*) |
| 1964 Lee S. Kersey, Jr. (*) |
| 1963 Lee S. Kersey, Jr. (*) |
| 1962 Clifton M. Rogers (*) |
| 1961 Herman H. Conoway (*) |
| 1960 J. Ralph Brittingham (*) |
| 1959 Robert K. Wyatt (*) |
| 1958 James E. Wharton (*) |
| 1957 Russell A. Lewis (*) |
| 1956 William A. Carter (*) |
| 1955 Frederick P. Whitney (*) |
| 1954 Lucien T. Lenhart (*) |
| 1953 Joseph R. Pittard (*) |
| 1952 John P. Gordy (*) |
| 1951 William Hitchens (*) |
| 1950 Horace J. Hickman (*) |
| 1949 A. Warren Wheatley (*) |
| 1948 Andrew J. Murray (*) |
| 1947 Emerson M. Keeler (*) |
| 1946 Irwin R. Murray (*) |
| 1945 James B. Carey (*) |
| 1944 William G. Cason (*) |
| 1943 Charles S. Calhoun (*) |
| 1942 James B. Hayman (*) |
| 1941 Harry H. Nichols (*) |
| 1940 Lloyd Short (*) |
| 1939 David R. Pepper (*) |
| 1938 George S. Buhl (*) |
| 1937 Wilson G. Boyer (*) |
| 1936 Dallas A. Dennis (*) |
| 1935 J. Ralph Carey (*) |
| 1934 Howard W. Bramhall (*) |
| 1933 Martin G. Phillips (*) |
| 1932 Harry T. Swain (*) |
| 1931 Fred H. Warrington (*) |
| 1930 Edwaed B. Green (*) |
| 1929 Ernest M. Rodgers (*) |
| 1928 Ernest M. Rodgers (*) |
| 1927 Norval L. Wilson (*) |
| 1926 Crawford B. Bailey (*) |
| 1925 Harold W. T. Purnell (*) |
| 1924 George O. Fearon (*) |
| 1923 Joseph E. Short (*) |
| 1922 George H. Short (*) |
| 1921 C. Edgar Willin (*) |
| 1920 Jehu F. Hudson (*) |
| 1919 Jehu F. Hudson (*) |
| 1918 William J. Mustard (*) |
| 1917 Lloyd P. Rayner (*) |
| 1916 Harvey P. Quatlander (*) |
| 1915 John E. Sammons (*) |
| 1914 Edward C. Morris (*) |
| 1913 Frank L. Hudson (*) |
| 1912 Oscar S. Wilson (*) |
| 1911 Minos O. Short (*) |
| 1910 William T. Hobbs (*) |
| 1909 Harry L. Holson (*) |
| 1907 Thomas B. Pepper (*) |
| 7-10-1906 David M. Reynolds (*) |
| 8-8-1905 Andrew J. Lynch (*) |
| 8-25-1904 Charles E. Willen (*) |
| 8-28-1903 James H. Chipman (*) |
| 7-8-1902 C. L. Moore (*) |
| 7-23-1901 Charles R. Jones (*) |
| 7-26-1898 J. L. Thompson (*) |
| 7-13-1897 W. S. Walls (*) |
| 6-23-1896 John W. Messick (*) |
| 6-25-1895 A. F. Polk (*) |
| 7-10-1894 William M. Vincent (*) |
| 7-11-1893 Theo. A. Polk (*) |
| 7-1-1892 John L. Thompson (*) |
| 7-21-1891 Charles L. Moore (*) |
| 3-25-1890 Joseph Cahall (*) |
| 7-10-1888 McKindree Downham (*) |
| 6-14-1887 Charles T. Purnell (*) |
| 6-23-1885 Jacob Moore (*) |
| 6-12-1883 B. F. Butler (*) |
| 6-22-1880 Hiram T. Downing (*) |
| 7-9-1878 Jacob Moore (*) |
| 6-22-1875 John R. McFee (*) |
| 7-8-1873 Charles T. Purnell (*) |
| 7-9-1872 Charles P. Tunnel (*) |
| 6-14-1870 Jacob Moore (*) |
| 8-10-1869 John S. Rodney (*) |
| 6-3-1868 Hiram T. Downing (*) |
| 6-26-1866 Jacob Moore (*) |
| 7-24-1860 Paynter Frame (*) |
| 7-12-1859 William Marshall (*) |
| 9-28-1858 Jacob Moore (*) |
| 6-23-1857 James M. Rench (*) |
| 2-5-1856 John R. McFee (*) |
| 6-6-1854 Charles C. Stockley (*) |
| 1-24-1854 Kendal B. Wingate (*) |
| 7-22-1851 John R. McFee (*) |
| 7-9-1850 John D. Rodney (*) |
| 6-12-1849 Laban L. Lyons (*) |
| 1-23-1849 James A. Parker (*) |
| 1-25-1848 James M. Rench (*) |
| 7-26-1846 Alfred P. Robinson (*) |
| 1-27-1846 Elias L. Rickard (*) |
| 12-28-1842 George Frame (*) |
| 12-22-1840 Joshua G. Baker (*) |
| 5-12-1840 George Frame (*) |
| 7-10-1838 Elias L. Rickard (*) |
| 6-6-1834 George Frame (*) |
| 6-19-1832 Joshua Layton (*) |
| 6-11-1831 Elias L. Rickard (*) |
| 7-27-1830 George Frame (*) |
| 1-12-1830 John Stockley (*) |
| 8-11-1829 Joshua L. Layton (*) |
| 6-12-1829 Elias L. Rickard (*) |
| 7-8-1828 George Frame (*) |
| 1-7-1828 Thomas Robinson (*) |
| 7-24-1827 David R. Smith (*) |
| 1-9-1827 Matthew Rench (*) |
| 7-25-1826 Asaph Buck (*) |
| 1-10-1826 Elias L. Rickard (*) |
| 7-19-1825 Asaph Buck (*) |
| 7-21-1823 Caleb L. Layton (*) |
| (*) Deceased |
| (**) Suspended |